Comparison

Detention vs Retention Stormwater Facilities

Detention basins release stormwater slowly. Retention facilities hold or infiltrate it. Compare objectives, infiltration, upkeep and local terms.

Civil & Structural · Last reviewed

Short answer: use detention to control the peak flow leaving a site, by storing runoff and releasing it at a limited rate. Use retention where the goal is to keep water on site, by infiltration, evaporation or a permanent pool, or to improve water quality. Local rules use these words differently, so check the definitions that apply.

DetentionRetention
Main purposeReduce the peak outflow to the pre-development rateHold or reduce the volume of runoff, and treat water quality
Normal conditionUsually dry between storms (a dry pond), or draining within daysHolds a permanent pool, or infiltrates, or stores water without surface discharge
DischargeControlled outlet to a stream or pipe, such as an orifice and a weirLittle or no discharge in smaller storms, with an overflow for large storms
InfiltrationMinor, if anyImportant in infiltration basins and ponds. Needs suitable soil
Site conditionsNeeds space and an outlet with enough downstream capacity and fallNeeds soil that drains, a low water table and distance from foundations and wells, or a liner and a permanent pool
Water qualityLimited settling during the short detention timeBetter, from settling, biological action and infiltration
MaintenanceOutlet cleaning, sediment removal, mowing, inspectionsSediment, vegetation, mosquito and algae management, and infiltration performance checks
RisksOutlet clogging, flooding if the volume is too smallGroundwater contamination if poorly sited, standing water issues
TerminologyCalled a dry pond or extended detention basinSome places call a wet pond a retention pond, others call it a wet detention pond

How to choose

  1. Read the local stormwater rules to see what is required: peak rate control, volume control, water quality or all.
  2. Check the soils and the groundwater, to see if infiltration is possible.
  3. Check the available space and the downstream conditions, including the outlet capacity.
  4. Size the storage for the design storms, with a routing calculation.
  5. Plan the maintenance, access and safety, including fencing and slopes where required.

Common mistakes

  • Assuming that the same word means the same thing in every jurisdiction.
  • Relying on infiltration without testing the soil, or siting a basin too near a building.
  • Sizing the storage with a single storm and ignoring the series of smaller and larger storms.
  • Leaving out the maintenance access and the emergency overflow path.

Related tools and labs

Calculators, labs and simulators are part of the All-Access Pass.

More comparisons

Questions

Can a facility do both?

Yes. Many designs combine a permanent pool for quality with extra storage above it for peak flow control, which is sometimes called wet detention.

Does detention reduce the total runoff?

No. It delays and spreads the same volume. Retention and infiltration reduce the volume that leaves the site.

Educational material. Examples use simplified, hypothetical inputs and are not a design, a construction document or professional engineering advice. Confirm requirements with the codes and standards adopted where the work is built and with a licensed engineer.

← All comparisons