Comparison

Wet vs Dry Pipe Sprinkler Systems

Wet systems hold water in the pipes and respond immediately. Dry systems hold pressurized air and are used where pipes could freeze. Compare response, cost, maintenance and use.

Fire Protection · Last reviewed

Short answer: use a wet-pipe system wherever the space stays above freezing. It is the simplest and most reliable type. Use a dry-pipe system for unheated spaces such as freezer areas, loading docks and parking structures open to the weather.

Wet-pipeDry-pipe
What is in the pipesWater under pressurePressurized air or nitrogen. A dry-pipe valve holds the water back
OperationA sprinkler opens and water flows at onceA sprinkler opens, air escapes, the valve trips, and water then fills the pipe and reaches the sprinkler
DelayNoneA water-delivery delay. The standard limits it in many occupancies, and larger systems may need accelerators
FreezingPipes must stay above freezingSuitable for spaces subject to freezing
Cost and complexityLowest. Few componentsHigher. Air supply, valve, trip testing and larger pipe sizing needs
MaintenanceSimple inspection and testingMore: air supply, low-point drains, trip tests, internal corrosion checks
Typical useOffices, hospitals, residences, most buildingsCold storage, unheated warehouses, canopies and loading docks

How to choose

  1. Can the space be kept above freezing? If so, use wet-pipe.
  2. If not, can the area be heated, or protected with an antifreeze system where allowed? Check the standard first.
  3. If dry-pipe is needed, size the system volume so the water-delivery time meets the standard, and plan for accelerators if it does not.
  4. Plan the maintenance: dry systems need trip tests and the removal of condensate and trapped water.
  5. Confirm the choice with the authority having jurisdiction and the governing standard (NFPA 13 in the United States).

Common mistakes

  • Using wet-pipe in a space that can freeze, because the heating is "usually on".
  • Not pitching dry-pipe lines to drain points, which leaves water that can freeze or corrode the pipe.
  • Oversizing a dry system without checking water-delivery time.

Two scenarios

An office building where every space is heated. A wet-pipe system is the simplest and most reliable, and it responds as soon as a sprinkler opens. There is no reason to use anything more complex.

An unheated warehouse loading dock in a cold climate. Water in the pipes would freeze, so a dry-pipe system holds air in the pipes and lets water in only when a sprinkler opens. The designer has to check the water delivery time.

Cost and life cycle

  • First cost: dry-pipe is higher because of the dry valve, the air supply and the larger pipe sizes often needed to meet the delivery time.
  • Maintenance: dry systems need trip tests, air-supply checks and draining of low points. Wet systems need less.
  • Corrosion: dry pipe corrodes faster inside because of oxygen and trapped water. Some systems use nitrogen to slow it.
  • Reliability: fewer moving parts favors wet-pipe where it can be used.

Related tools and labs

Calculators, labs and simulators are part of the All-Access Pass.

More comparisons

Questions

What is a pre-action system?

A system that needs a second event, such as detection, before water enters the pipes. It is used where an accidental discharge would be costly, such as data and archive rooms.

Are dry systems less reliable?

They have more parts that can fail and need more maintenance, so they are used only where required.

What is an antifreeze system?

A wet system filled with an antifreeze solution, for small unheated areas. The standard limits where and how it can be used.

What is a water delivery time?

The time from a sprinkler opening to water reaching it in a dry-pipe system. The standard sets a limit for many occupancies, and larger systems may need a quick-opening device.

Who decides which system is required?

The designer chooses within the standard, and the authority having jurisdiction approves it. The building use and temperature drive the choice.

Educational material. Examples use simplified, hypothetical inputs and are not a design, a construction document or professional engineering advice. Confirm requirements with the codes and standards adopted where the work is built and with a licensed engineer.

← All comparisons