4–20 mA vs 0–10 V: Which Analog Signal Should You Use?
4–20 mA resists noise and long cables and flags a broken wire. 0–10 V is simple but noise-prone. Compare length, grounding and fault detection.
Controls & Instrumentation · Last reviewed
Short answer: use 4–20 mA for field instruments, long cable runs and electrically noisy plants, because it is robust and tells you when the wire is broken. 0–10 V is acceptable for short runs inside panels and in building controls, where simplicity and low cost matter.
| 4–20 mA | 0–10 V | |
|---|---|---|
| Signal type | Current, the same in all parts of the loop | Voltage, which can drop in the wiring and pick up noise |
| Cable length | Long runs are fine, up to the loop compliance limit | Best for short runs |
| Noise immunity | High, because the receiver has a low impedance and the current is not changed by noise | Lower, because the receiver has a high impedance that picks up interference |
| Fault detection | The live zero means 0% is 4 mA, so 0 mA (a broken wire) is detectable | A zero reading can be a true zero or a broken wire |
| Powering the device | A 2-wire transmitter can be powered from the loop itself | The device needs a separate power supply |
| Input compatibility | The receiver uses a shunt resistor, such as 250 Ω for 1 to 5 V | High-impedance input, often 100 kΩ or more |
| Grounding | Less sensitive, but one point of the loop should be grounded | Sensitive to ground potential differences |
| Multiple receivers | Wired in series, and the sum of their resistances counts | Wired in parallel, if the source can drive them |
| Cost and ease | Slightly more costly, common in industrial plants | Cheap and simple, common in HVAC controllers |
Related tools and labs
Calculators, labs and simulators are part of the All-Access Pass.
More comparisons
- PLC vs DCS: Which Control System for the Plant?
- RTD vs Thermocouple: Which Temperature Sensor Fits?
- Two-Wire vs Four-Wire Transmitters
- Modbus RTU vs Modbus TCP
- BACnet vs Modbus: Which Protocol Fits Building Automation?
- PLC vs Microcontroller: Which Controller Fits?
- VFD vs Soft Starter: Which One for an AC Induction Motor?
- Star-Delta vs Direct-on-Line Motor Starting
Questions
Why does 4–20 mA start at 4?
So that a loop-powered transmitter has current to run on at zero measurement, and so that a failure to 0 mA is clearly different from a valid zero reading.
Can I convert between them?
Yes. Signal converters or a shunt resistor change a current to a voltage. A converter can also isolate the two sides.
Educational material. Examples use simplified, hypothetical inputs and are not a design, a construction document or professional engineering advice. Confirm requirements with the codes and standards adopted where the work is built and with a licensed engineer.