Radar vs Ultrasonic Level Measurement
Radar ignores vapor and temperature. Ultrasonic costs less but is affected by vapor and foam. Compare range, obstructions and geometry.
Controls & Instrumentation · Last reviewed
Short answer: ultrasonic is a good low-cost choice for clean, simple applications such as open tanks and sumps at ambient conditions. Radar is the better choice when there is vapor, steam, temperature or pressure changes, foam or dust, or when you need a narrow beam to avoid obstructions.
| Radar (non-contact) | Ultrasonic | |
|---|---|---|
| Principle | Microwave pulses (or a frequency sweep) reflected from the surface | Sound pulses reflected from the surface |
| Vapor and condensation | Largely unaffected | Affected, because vapor changes the speed of sound and weakens the echo |
| Temperature | Not affected by air temperature | Needs compensation, because the speed of sound changes with temperature |
| Pressure and gas composition | Not affected in most applications | Affected |
| Foam | Can see through light foam, depending on the frequency and the foam, and the signal may be reduced | Foam absorbs sound, which weakens the echo |
| Dust and heavy agitation | Better handling, especially at higher frequencies | Dust and turbulence can disturb the signal |
| Beam width | Narrow at 80 GHz, which avoids tank walls and internals | Wider beam (about 10° is typical), so obstructions can interfere |
| Range | Up to tens of meters, with accuracy of a few millimeters | A few meters to tens of meters, with accuracy of a few millimeters to centimeters |
| Cost | Higher, although it has been falling | Lower |
Related tools and labs
Calculators, labs and simulators are part of the All-Access Pass.
More comparisons
- PLC vs DCS: Which Control System for the Plant?
- RTD vs Thermocouple: Which Temperature Sensor Fits?
- 4–20 mA vs 0–10 V: Which Analog Signal Should You Use?
- Two-Wire vs Four-Wire Transmitters
- Modbus RTU vs Modbus TCP
- BACnet vs Modbus: Which Protocol Fits Building Automation?
- VFD vs Soft Starter: Which One for an AC Induction Motor?
- Star-Delta vs Direct-on-Line Motor Starting
Questions
Is radar always better?
It handles harder conditions, but costs more. For a clean, ambient application, ultrasonic often gives all the accuracy you need.
What about a guided-wave radar?
A guided-wave radar uses a probe, which helps with small tanks, foam and a tank with internals, and it is a contact device.
Educational material. Examples use simplified, hypothetical inputs and are not a design, a construction document or professional engineering advice. Confirm requirements with the codes and standards adopted where the work is built and with a licensed engineer.