Comparison

Online vs Line-Interactive UPS: Which One Do You Need?

Online UPS powers the load from its inverter at all times. Line-interactive switches to battery on failure. Compare quality, transfer, efficiency and cost.

Electrical & Power · Last reviewed

Short answer: a line-interactive UPS suits most office workstations, network edge equipment and other loads that can ride through a few milliseconds of transfer. An online UPS suits critical loads that need clean, continuous power, such as server rooms, labs and sensitive process equipment, and it costs more to buy and run.

Online (double conversion)Line-interactive
How the load is fedAlways from the inverter. Input is rectified, then invertedFrom the utility through a voltage regulator. The inverter takes over on a failure
Transfer to batteryNo transfer time, because the inverter already feeds the loadA few milliseconds, typically within the hold-up time of modern power supplies
Power quality at the outputRegenerated, regulated voltage and frequency, isolated from input disturbancesVoltage is corrected by boost and buck. Frequency follows the utility. Small units may give a simulated sine wave on battery
EfficiencyLower in double-conversion mode, with an efficient "eco" mode on many modelsHigher, because most of the time only the regulator is in the path
Heat and coolingMore heat, so more cooling and ventilationLess heat
Battery stressThe charger runs continuously, and the battery sees the input all the timeBattery is idle on float most of the time
Cost and maintenanceHigher purchase cost and more electronics to maintainLower purchase cost and simpler
Standards class (IEC 62040-3)VFI: output independent of voltage and frequencyVI: output independent of voltage only

Office workstation versus server room

Office workstationServer room
LoadOne computer and monitor, about 300 WServers and network gear, tens of kilowatts
Cost of an outage or glitchLost work, a restartService downtime, possible data damage, a failed backup window
Power quality problemsOccasional sags and surgesSags, harmonics, generator frequency drift, input noise
Backup sourceUtility only. The UPS saves the file and shuts downOften a generator, which the UPS must ride through until it starts
FitLine-interactive is usually enoughOnline is the usual choice, often in a redundant (N+1) arrangement

Modern computer power supplies hold up for roughly 10 to 20 ms at full load, which is longer than a line-interactive transfer. A server room may also run from a generator whose voltage and frequency vary during start-up and load steps, and the online UPS isolates the load from that.

How to choose

  1. List the load and what a glitch or an outage costs. Higher costs push toward online.
  2. Check the quality of the utility or generator supply. A poor supply favors online.
  3. Check the load requirements: sine-wave output on battery, power factor and transfer tolerance. Some active-PFC power supplies misbehave on a simulated sine wave.
  4. Compare running cost: efficiency losses and cooling over the life, not only the purchase price.
  5. Size for the load with room to grow, and plan battery maintenance.

Common mistakes

  • Buying online capacity for a load that does not need it, then paying for the losses and cooling for years.
  • Choosing a line-interactive UPS with a simulated sine-wave output for equipment that needs a pure sine wave.
  • Judging by VA only. Check the watt rating and the power factor as well.
  • Forgetting generator compatibility: the UPS input behavior with a generator matters.

Related tools and labs

Calculators, labs and simulators are part of the All-Access Pass.

More comparisons

Questions

Is the transfer time of a line-interactive UPS a problem?

For most computers it is not, because their power supplies ride through a short gap. Check the load specification for sensitive or older equipment.

What is eco mode?

An online UPS can pass utility power directly to the load when it is within limits, and switch to double conversion when it is not. It saves energy with a short transfer in some conditions, so check the manufacturer data.

Educational material. Examples use simplified, hypothetical inputs and are not a design, a construction document or professional engineering advice. Confirm requirements with the codes and standards adopted where the work is built and with a licensed engineer.

← All comparisons